How to Choose the Right Metal Detector for Coins, Jewellery and Relic Hunting

How to choose the right metal detector

Choosing your first metal detector can feel overwhelming. With so many brands, features and price ranges available, it’s easy to wonder which detector is right for you.

The good news is that there is no single “best” metal detector for everyone. The right choice depends on what you want to find, where you plan to search and your level of experience.

This guide will help you understand the key features to consider before purchasing a metal detector.

What Do You Want to Find?

The first question to ask is what you are hoping to discover.

Coins and Jewellery

If your goal is finding modern coins, rings and jewellery in parks, sports fields and beaches, most modern VLF detectors will perform well.

Look for:

  • Good target identification
  • Adjustable discrimination
  • Lightweight design
  • Waterproof search coil

Historical Relics

Relic hunters often search older sites for military items, artefacts and historical objects.

Look for:

  • Excellent depth
  • Fast target recovery speed
  • Multiple search modes
  • Good performance in mineralised soil

Beach Detecting

Saltwater beaches present unique challenges for metal detectors.

Look for:

  • Multi-frequency technology
  • Waterproof construction
  • Stable operation in wet sand
  • Detectors that have dedicated beach mode or salt mode.

Choosing the Right Detector for Your Experience Level

Beginners

New detectorists should focus on simplicity and ease of use rather than advanced features.

A good beginner detector should:

  • Be easy to learn
  • Have automatic settings available
  • Be lightweight and comfortable
  • Offer good value for money

Recommended options:
Quest X5 IdMaxX
Minelab Vanquish 360

Intermediate Users

Once you gain experience, you may want greater control over detector settings and improved performance.

Intermediate users often benefit from:

  • Multi-frequency technology
  • More advanced target identification
  • Additional search modes
  • Better separation in trashy areas

Recommended options:
XP ICON X
Garrett Vortex VX9
Minelab X-Terra Elite

Advanced Detectorists

Experienced users often want maximum performance and complete control over detector settings.

Advanced detectors may offer:

  • Extensive customisation
  • Superior target separation
  • Faster recovery speed
  • Enhanced performance in difficult conditions

Recommended options:
XP DEUS II
Minelab Manticore

Important Features Explained

Target Identification

Target ID provides a numerical indication of what may be beneath the ground before digging.

While no detector can identify targets with 100% accuracy, Target ID can help reduce unnecessary digging.

Discrimination

Discrimination allows certain unwanted targets to be ignored while still detecting desirable items.

This can be useful in areas containing large amounts of rubbish.

Multi-Frequency Technology

Modern multi-frequency detectors can operate on multiple frequencies simultaneously.

This generally provides improved performance across a wider range of target types and ground conditions.

Waterproofing

If you plan to search beaches, rivers or wet environments, waterproof capabilities are highly recommended.

Common Mistakes When Buying a Metal Detector

Many beginners purchase advanced detectors with complex settings that are never utilised. However for some, purchasing an advanced detector that you can grow into the hobby with is preferred – so this is a personal choice.

A detector that feels comfortable after several hours of use is often a better choice than one with slightly more features.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the best metal detector for a beginner?

The best beginner detector is one that is easy to use, lightweight and offers good target identification. Consider your budget and intended use before making a decision. Have a browse through our entry level detector range.

How deep can metal detector detect?

Depth depends on many factors including coil size, target size, soil conditions, shape of target, type of metal of the target and detector settings. Because these variables will always change, depth will always vary under the different conditions.

Can one detector find coins, jewellery and relics?

Yes. Most modern detectors are versatile enough to successfully locate all three.

Are expensive detectors always better?

Not necessarily. Higher-end detectors often provide more features and improved performance, but many entry-level detectors can achieve excellent results in the right hands.

Do I need a permit to metal detect in South Africa?

In South Africa, prospecting or mining for gold requires an official permit or right from the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy.

However, metal detecting recreationally at public parks and beaches does not require any permits.

Still Need Help Choosing?

At Treasure Hunters, we stock a wide range of metal detectors from leading manufacturers including Garrett, Minelab, XP and Quest metal detectors.

If you’re unsure which detector is right for your needs, contact our team for expert advice and personalised recommendations.